Darl Messy
Wedding DJs have relied on Neil Diamond for about fifty years, and for good reason. His catalogue does something very specific to a room full of people who have been drinking and are already emotional. Here are twenty things that happen the moment one of his songs arrives.
1. The dance floor fills within about four seconds
There is no polite hesitation. Diamond’s up-tempo material produces immediate movement because everybody in the room already knows it and nobody has to work out whether they like it first.
2. Three generations arrive simultaneously
The bride’s grandmother and the bride’s nephew get there at the same moment. Very few records on a wedding playlist can do that, which is precisely why DJs keep them in the bag.
3. Somebody’s father takes over completely
Every wedding has one, and Diamond is his moment. Full commitment, no self-consciousness, arms out. The songs were built to be sung by people who cannot sing, which gives him every possible encouragement.
4. The volume from the floor exceeds the speakers
A room that was making ordinary noise becomes the loudest thing in the building. This is the single clearest indicator that a wedding has properly turned the corner.
5. People who refused to dance all evening give in
Resistance has a poor record here. Refusing to join in becomes more conspicuous than joining in, and the holdouts fold somewhere around the second chorus.
6. Somebody starts the response too early
Enthusiasm outruns timing every single time. The room corrects itself within a beat and nobody minds at all — it has effectively become part of the arrangement.
7. The bride and groom get pulled into the middle
Whether they wanted to be or not. There is a gravitational quality to a Diamond singalong that ends with the newlyweds surrounded, which somebody will photograph and everybody will keep.
8. The slow numbers empty it out for couples
His ballads do the opposite job just as reliably. The room clears for pairs, and a considerable number of people end up dancing to material written by a Brooklyn songwriter born in 1941.
9. Older relatives visibly relax
They have been sitting politely through music they do not know for two hours. This is the point where they recognise something, and their whole posture changes.
10. Nobody checks their phone
For roughly three and a half minutes an entire wedding is doing the same thing at the same time, which is rarer at modern receptions than it used to be.
11. Somebody claims it as “our song”
Given how many weddings have used this material across fifty years, an enormous number of couples have attached one of these records to their own history permanently.
12. The photographer gets their best shot of the night
Arms up, everyone singing, generations mixed together. Wedding photographers know exactly which songs produce that frame, and Diamond is on the short list.
13. Somebody who claimed to hate it is singing loudest
This is close to a rule. Public dislike of “Sweet Caroline” tends not to survive contact with a room that has decided to sing it.
14. Nobody worries about being in tune
The songs actively reward imprecision. A crowd singing flat, late and far too loud sounds better rather than worse, because volume and commitment are entirely the point.
15. The DJ stops working for a minute
The correct move with this material is to get out of its way. Once a room has taken it over, the best thing anyone with a microphone can do is nothing at all.
16. It gets requested again later
Frequently within the hour. Diamond is one of the few artists a wedding will happily hear twice in one night without complaint.
17. Somebody explains that he wrote “I’m A Believer”
There is always one. It is true — he wrote it for The Monkees before he had a performing career of his own — and it surprises at least one person at every wedding it is mentioned at.
18. Strangers end up with their arms round each other
People who met that afternoon, singing sideways at each other rather than at the DJ. That is the specific behaviour Diamond’s writing produces and it is unusual for recorded music to trigger it.
19. The energy carries into the next three songs
A properly executed Diamond singalong leaves the floor full, which is why DJs place it strategically rather than randomly. It does structural work for the rest of the evening.
20. Somebody remembers a wedding from thirty years ago
The same song, a different room, people who are no longer here. His catalogue has been attached to family occasions for so long that it now carries other people’s memories as well as the present one.
The bottom line: Diamond wrote most of this material to be commercially useful, in New York, to deadline. It ended up embedded in a very large number of people’s most significant days, which is a considerably better outcome than the brief ever called for.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings