Darl Messy
Before Neil Diamond was a performer, he was a writer supplying material to other people. Even after he became a star, his songs continued to be recorded by artists across every genre, sometimes becoming better known in someone else’s version. Here are twenty things worth knowing about that side of his work.
1. He Started As A Writer For Hire
Diamond entered the music business producing songs for other performers rather than for himself, working in New York’s song-writing industry after leaving a pre-med course. That starting point shaped everything about how he writes — he learned to serve a song and a singer rather than to express himself, and the habit never left him.
2. “I’m A Believer” Was His Breakthrough
His composition became an enormous hit for The Monkees, and for a period it was the most commercially successful thing he had written. Diamond was not on the record, did not perform it and was not visible in its success, which makes it the purest possible demonstration of his songwriting ability.
3. It Proved He Understood Mass Appeal
Writing something that large for another act proved he understood what millions of people respond to. That instinct was trained rather than innate: years of producing material to order, watching which songs publishers accepted and which they rejected, teaches a writer very quickly what actually works at scale.
4. “Red Red Wine” Was Transformed
“Red Red Wine” was written by Diamond and later reinterpreted in an entirely different musical tradition, becoming a global hit in that version. Many people who know the song well have no idea he wrote it, which is a striking illustration of how completely a composition can separate from its author.
5. Reinterpretation Extends A Song’s Life
A song recorded across multiple genres reaches audiences the original version could never have found. Diamond’s catalogue has been taken up by pop, rock, country and reggae performers, and each of those recordings introduced his writing to listeners who would never have sought out one of his own albums.
6. “Girl, You’ll Be A Woman Soon” Found New Life
“Girl, You’ll Be A Woman Soon” found significant new life through later film use, introducing it to a generation with no knowledge of its origins. That pattern — his material resurfacing through channels entirely outside the music industry — has kept the catalogue circulating continuously for six decades.
7. Covers Generate Independent Income
Every recording of a song by another artist earns the writer money regardless of who performs it, and Diamond retained ownership of his compositions. With a catalogue as widely covered as his, that income stream operates continuously and independently of whether he releases or performs anything himself.
8. His Songs Suit Other Voices
Because he trained writing for other performers, his material was never dependent on his own particular delivery. A song built around one distinctive voice collapses when someone else attempts it; Diamond’s songs were constructed to be handed over from the beginning, which is why they survive the transfer.
9. The Structures Are Adaptable
Simple, well-built songs can be rearranged into almost any style without falling apart. Strip a Diamond composition down to melody, chords and lyric and it still works, which means an arranger in any genre has something solid to build on. Complicated songs rarely offer that flexibility.
10. Country Artists Recorded Him
Country artists have recorded his work repeatedly, and the fit is natural. His storytelling instinct, his concrete detail and his melodic directness all sit comfortably within country arrangements, and the emotional sincerity that defines his writing is central to that genre rather than at odds with it.
11. Rock Acts Covered Him
Rock acts have covered him too, drawn to the rhythmic drive in much of his up-tempo material. Songs like “Cracklin’ Rosie” carry enough momentum to withstand a harder treatment, and the underlying structures are robust enough that added weight does not obscure the melody.
12. Reggae Reinterpretation Worked
One of the most commercially successful versions of his work came from a completely different musical tradition entirely. That a song written by a Brooklyn-born pop songwriter in the 1960s could become a reggae-influenced global hit says a great deal about the durability of what he built.
13. Ballads Were Widely Recorded
His slower songs have been taken up repeatedly by singers looking for emotional material that does not require them to shout. Diamond wrote sincerity without embarrassment, and that quality is difficult to find and highly valuable to any vocalist looking for a ballad with genuine feeling in it.
14. Some Listeners Do Not Know He Wrote Them
A considerable number of people can sing songs he wrote with no idea of his involvement, which is a mark of how thoroughly they entered common culture. Diamond has spoken about this without resentment — a song that no longer needs its author has arguably achieved the most a song can.
15. The Songwriters Hall Of Fame Recognised This
His induction into the Songwriters Hall of Fame specifically honoured the writing rather than his performing career. That distinction matters, because his catalogue’s value as compositions is separable from his own recordings of them, and the institution recognised exactly that.
16. Two Halls Of Fame Is Rare
Being inducted into both the Songwriters and the Rock and Roll Halls of Fame reflects excellence in two genuinely distinct disciplines. Very few figures in popular music hold both, because writing songs for other people and performing them yourself require different skills that rarely coexist at that level.
17. He Kept The Publishing Value
Owning his compositions meant the catalogue retained value entirely separate from record sales. It also kept the authorship clear: when other artists had hits with his songs, the credit and the income both stayed with him rather than dispersing into the industry as happened to many writers of his generation.
18. Covers Introduced Him To New Generations
Younger listeners frequently encounter a modern cover first and work backwards to the original. That route has introduced Diamond’s catalogue to people born decades after the songs were written, and it continues to operate now without requiring any promotional activity from him at all.
19. He Continued Writing After Retiring
Following his 2018 Parkinson’s diagnosis, which ended his touring career, Diamond indicated he intended to keep writing and recording. Songwriting does not demand the physical stamina touring does, and it was in any case where his career began — the job he took up in New York in the first place.
20. The Songs Outlive Every Version
No single recording is definitive. A well-written song survives every performer who takes it on, and Diamond’s have survived a great many across sixty years and four or five genres. That is the real measure of the craft, and it is why the catalogue will continue long after every version currently in circulation.
The bottom line: Diamond’s catalogue is strong enough that other artists keep returning to it. Songs that survive being handed to someone else entirely are the ones built properly in the first place.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings