Darl Messy
You could tell a Neil Diamond audience apart from any other arena crowd within about ninety seconds of walking in. Across roughly five decades of touring, the room developed a character of its own. Here are twenty things you would notice about the people in it.
1. The average age is high and nobody minds
By his later tours the crowd skewed considerably older than most arena shows, and there was no self-consciousness about it whatsoever. Nobody was pretending to be a demographic they were not, which made the whole room more relaxed.
2. But there are far more young people than you expect
Dragged along, initially, and then singing every word by the fourth song. The songs are accessible enough that nobody needs a background in sixties pop to get on board within a few minutes.
3. Couples who met to this music
A significant number of people in any Diamond crowd will tell you one of these songs was played at their wedding. His ballads are a wedding-DJ staple, so his catalogue is attached to a great many personal histories.
4. People who have brought their parents
And people who have brought their children. The three-generation row is entirely standard rather than remarkable, which is how a touring career sustains itself for fifty years rather than fading with its original audience.
5. Nobody is there ironically
This is unusual. Plenty of heritage acts attract an audience half-attending as a joke. Diamond crowds turned up because they liked the songs, without any protective layer of irony, and it changed the temperature of the room.
6. A high proportion of repeat attendees
Ask around and you will find people counting off tours going back decades. They were not there to discover anything new; they went every time he came through, and had done for thirty years.
7. People dressed up more than the venue required
Jackets and good shoes at an arena show. For a lot of the audience this was the concert they went to, and they treated it accordingly.
8. Almost no phones during the quiet songs
The ballads got listened to properly. Given how much of a modern audience films everything continuously, the attention his slower material commanded was noticeable.
9. Then every phone up for “Sweet Caroline”
The exception is total. The song generates its own footage in venues worldwide, which is a substantial part of why it keeps reaching people who have never heard the album version.
10. Crying that nobody hides
His songs deal with loneliness and loss without hedging, and audiences responded openly. Weeping at a concert is normally concealed. In that room it was ordinary and nobody around them thought it strange.
11. Strangers talking to each other in the queue
The pre-show atmosphere was sociable rather than transactional. People compared which tours they had seen, which is not typical queue behaviour at most arena events.
12. Singing aimed sideways rather than at the stage
The defining behaviour. Diamond’s material was built for group participation, and in his crowds people sang to whoever was next to them rather than towards the performer.
13. Very few people leaving early
At most arena shows a steady stream heads out during the encore. Given the average age of a Diamond audience you would expect more of it, and there was less.
14. People who own none of his records
Radio, weddings, sport and films did the work. A meaningful chunk of any crowd had never bought an album and could still sing most of the set without effort.
15. Somebody explaining the songwriting to whoever they brought
There is always one person telling their companion that he wrote “I’m A Believer”, that he left a pre-med course to do it, and that he was writing for other artists in New York before anyone knew his name.
16. Genuine warmth towards the man on stage
Not just enthusiasm for the songs. Sixty years of material attached to weddings, car journeys and family occasions produces something closer to affection, and it was audible.
17. An audience that actually listens between songs
He talked to the room, and the room paid attention. That two-way quality is difficult to establish in a venue built for twenty thousand and was central to his live reputation.
18. People from a long way away
Travel and hotels booked around a date. His shows had the standing of events rather than casual nights out, which is earned slowly across decades of consistent concerts.
19. Total, immediate standing on certain intros
Recognition was instant and collective. The songs are so widely known that a room identified them simultaneously and reacted as one, faster than at most concerts.
20. Nobody in a hurry to go home afterwards
The car parks emptied slowly. People stood around finishing conversations they had started with strangers, which is the clearest sign that what happened inside was social rather than merely musical.
The bottom line: Diamond retired from touring in 2018 following a Parkinson’s diagnosis, so these rooms no longer assemble. What they demonstrated is that he was never really selling a concert — he was selling a few hours of being among people, and the songs were how he did it.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings